Prophet's Point is a small sandbar located in the southwestern branch of Prophet's Creek. Before becoming known as "Prophet's Point," the island had a Wenrohronon name that is commonly translated to "Everlasting Land" or "Timeless Island."

At one time, the Point was connected to Prophecy Creek proper by way of a stone arch bridge that had been built by the Wenro in the mid-17th Century, but the bridge collapsed during the Valentine's Day earthquake of 1951. Arranged on the Point are four standing stones known colloquially as the Four Brothers.

In June of 1997, Phil Michener, Ben Kelerick, and Michael Everett ventured out to the Point in an attempt to examine the stones in relation to Sebastian Hunter and an unidentified dead man.